It seems like yesterday, but 15 years have passed: what is the telescope effect that influences the perception of time

The telescope effect (or telescoping effect) is a cognitive bias of our autobiographical memory which consists in the inability to temporally place an event correctly, making us perceive it as closer to the present (forward telescoping) or further away (backward telescoping).

It is therefore not a question of the inability to recall the memory itself, but of an error in its dating: the problem is not “what do I remember?”, but “when did it happen?”.

Let’s try to think, for example, of a person we have known for many years. We probably know how to tell how we met: where we were, who introduced us, even some details of the first conversation. But if someone asked us: “What year did it happen?”, we might answer “10 years ago”, only to discover that, in reality, 15 years have passed.

More generally, something similar will probably have happened to us with other events in our lives: a holiday, the start of a relationship, a change of job or a particularly important episode. We may remember very well what happened, but be less sure of when: a form of inaccuracy in what psychologists call “temporal localization.”

Memory is not a calendar

When we recall an event, we must not imagine that a sort of archive labeled, for example, “March 15, 2012” is preserved in our mind.

To establish the precise date, we often have to carry out a reconstruction of that event using the information we can recover: the people present, how we were dressed, the place, the season or what we were doing in that period.

The brain, however, can be conditioned by some elements:

  • Amount of accessible information: In 1985 Brown, Rips and Shevell formulated what they called accessibility principle. In some experiments on the memory of public events they observed that events about which people were able to recover more information tended to be judged as more recent. In other words, when a memory is very rich and easily accessible, this abundance of information can become one of the clues used by memory to estimate how much time has passed. But this doesn’t always mean that “more details = more recent event”. Accessibility is only one of the cues that memory can use.
  • Temporal anchors: to understand when something happened, we can connect it to other events that function as reference points (or temporal landmarks). We may think, “It happened when I still lived in that house,” “It was the summer before I started college,” “It was shortly after I changed my old job.” These references help to build a sort of map of the past. When they are easily recoverable, they can allow us to narrow down the temporal location of a memory; when they become more smoky, dating can become more uncertain.
  • If the events are similar, dating becomes more difficult: it is relatively easy to remember a particular holiday, a wedding or a move: they are distinctive events, emotionally significant and with many specific characteristics. But if we need to establish when a particular dinner, walk or training session occurred, the task becomes much more complicated. In other words, when events are very similar to each other, or more frequent, they can easily get confused.
  • Age also matters: SE Crawley and L. Pring observed that, with increasing age, forward telescoping decreases and, for more distant events, backward telescoping may appear. A possible factor to consider is that the perception of the passage of time changes throughout life: in some periods we may have the sensation that time passes very quickly, in others more slowly. This perception can influence how we reconstruct the temporal distance of an event and, consequently, make it more difficult to establish when it actually happened.

Telescope effect: There is no single direction of error

In short, telescoping is a truly complex phenomenon, due to a series of mechanisms that DC Rubin and AD Baddeley tried to describe in 1989, in the study “Telescoping is not time compression”.

Their model suggests that it is not necessary to imagine telescoping as a simple “time compression” in memory but can emerge from the combination of several processes:

  • recent events are generally more easily recoverable;
  • dating errors increase with elapsed time;
  • Furthermore, when we look for events belonging to a certain range, we can also include episodes that were actually just outside that period. (Let’s imagine, for example, that we want to remember all the events that occurred “in the last six months”: an episode that occurred seven months ago could be perceived as close enough to still fit into our reconstruction.)

The point, then, is that there is no single mechanism responsible for the telescope effect. The date we attribute to a memory can depend on the amount of information available, the temporal references we are able to recover, the distance of the event, its distinctiveness and the context in which we remember it.

In any case, based on the scientific literature available up to that point, the idea was consolidated that the further away an event was in time, the more recent it tended to be remembered, i.e. with an increase in forward telescoping.

Another perspective emerged from DB Burt, S. Kemp and MA Conway in 2001, in the study “What happens if you retest autobiographical memory 10 years on?”. The researchers recontacted 11 people who had already been studied ten years earlier and compared the new estimates of event dates with previous ones and with the dates recorded in their diaries.

The result? It did not increase forward telescoping as one might expect; on the contrary, backward telescoping predominated in the new estimates. That is, events were placed further back in the past.

The study then showed that the mere passage of time alone does not necessarily determine the direction in which a memory will move. In short, dating errors do not follow a precise rule.

Studies on the perception of time: the question also matters

At this point we can take a further step. Imagine someone asks us, “Did this event happen within the last five years?” It’s a different question than, “When exactly did this happen?”

In the first case we must above all establish whether the memory belongs to a certain interval or not. In the second, however, we must try to reconstruct a more precise temporal position. This is precisely the point highlighted by the 1998 study by V. Prohaska, NR Brown and RF Belli, “Forward telescoping: The question matters”.

The authors showed that changing the wording of the questions could impact the amount of forward telescoping observed. The result, that is, suggests that memory does not always respond in the same way when we ask it to place an event in time. Changing the question means, in part, also changing the task that the memory will have to perform, influencing its reconstruction.

The question becomes even more interesting when the way we ask to express time changes. SMJ Janssen, AG Chessa, and JMJ Murre compared answers phrased in absolute terms, such as “July 2004,” with relative answers, such as “three weeks ago.” They found that dates expressed in absolute terms were, overall, more accurate than those expressed in relative terms.

The effect, however, also depended on the type and distance of the event: for the most recent events a small backward telescoping appeared, while for the more distant ones a marked forward telescoping emerged. This result helps us understand that the precision with which we remember a date also depends on the task we ask our memory to perform and the nature of the event to be recalled.

Let’s think about a very simple example. Remembering the last time we went to the doctor is a relatively limited task: there is a specific episode to identify. It’s different to ask to remember all the times we did physical activity in the last month.

In this second case the episodes are numerous, frequent and often similar to each other. We must first distinguish one experience from another and then assign a temporal location to each. The request for a precise date, therefore, does not automatically make the memory accurate: when the events are distinctive and easily identifiable it can help, while when they are frequent and similar to each other dating remains more difficult.

What can we conclude with certainty?

There is no single rule that tells us in which direction memory will move an event over time. Some studies have found a greater tendency towards forward telescoping, in others backward telescoping; in some cases the error changes with the distance of the event, in others with age, with the type of memory or even with the way in which the question is asked. It doesn’t mean that research hasn’t found an explanation.

Rather, it means that the dating of a memory appears to depend on the interaction of many factors and that there is a clear distinction between remembering an event and reconstructing its position in time.