It’s not just Italy that has been recalled this time. The European Commission has opened infringement proceedings against six other countries. Germany, Spain, Austria, Poland, Portugal and Romania were also called out for the tax treatment meted out to pension funds and life insurance companies based abroad.
According to Brussels, the tax rules of Italy and other states violate European rules on the free movement of capital, penalizing foreign operators compared to national ones.
Who are the operators involved and why is the EU dealing with them
At the center of the recall are financial and social security operators: essentially, these are insurance companies that sell life insurance policies and supplementary pension funds that have their registered office in another country of the European Union or the European Economic Area, but which collect savings or invest capital in the European single market.
In the single market, a citizen must be able to take out a life insurance policy or a pension plan with a company outside the national soil without changing the tax conditions, just as a foreign pension fund that invests in securities or real estate in the EU should not suffer worse treatment than a national fund. Brussels’ action is focused precisely on this balance, which aims to build a single savings and investment union without barriers between states.
The two charges
In the letter sent to the Italian government, the European Commission contests two specific tax disparities that make it less convenient for a foreign operator to work or invest on the national market.
Taxation on income
When a pension fund or insurance company invests its clients’ money in stocks, bonds or funds, it generates financial gains. According to Brussels, the laws of each state involved grant exemptions or tax breaks on these returns to national operators, while fully taxing foreign operators who carry out the exact same activity.
The deduction of technical reserves
Insurance companies and pension funds are obliged to set aside sums of money every year, so-called technical reserveswhich serve to ensure that in the future there is money ready to pay pensions or pay out life insurance policies for insured persons. While domestic operators can deduct these provisions from their income, foreign operators are denied this deduction.
What happens now and what Italy risks
The letter of formal notice represents the first formal step of the community infringement procedure. Italy and the other countries involved now have two months to respond to the European Commission’s observations and change their tax rules to eliminate the unequal treatment, as happened for Green Homes.
If within sixty days the answers provided by the government are not considered satisfactory, Brussels will send a reasoned opinion, a precursor to possible financial sanctions. On a practical level for savers, the adjustment requested by Europe aims to increase competition between European social security and insurance products, reducing indirect fiscal costs which often end up weighing on the net returns of policies and pension funds.









